“How to Interview a Scrum Master” from Paolo Sammicheli, Agile Business Coach and Scrum Trainer
Are you an Agile Coach, Scrum of Scrums Master, Chief Product Owner, or Human Resources Hiring Manager looking for a valuable tool to help hire Scrum Masters at your organization? Look no further. Scrum Trainer by Scrum Inc. and Scrum@Scale Trainer Paolo Sammicheli presents his process for identifying suitable candidates for several companies. Paolo Sammicheli is an Italian Entrepreneur, International Speaker, and Author of the book “Scrum for Hardware,” the first significant publication in the world on the topic. Today Paolo works as an Agile Business Coach, specialized in Scrum, Scrum@Scale, Kanban, Design Thinking, and Lean Startup. He helps organizations uncover better ways of delighting their customers. Paolo is currently working on his next book, “Scrum in AI.” The book comprises Agility’s foundations, a detailed description of the methods, the engineering practices, and case studies with real examples and suggestions on how to implement them in your company. “How to Interview a Scrum Master” [View Original] The selection of a Scrum Master is not defined anywhere in the Scrum Guide. Who chooses them? With which criteria? Different methods can be observed across Agile Organizations: in some cases, the Scrum Master is set up voluntarily and is then appointed by the management; in others, they were born as a member of the Team and elected within it, and often partly continue to carry out development activities, as a team member. At the beginning of 2018, one of my clients needed to reorganize the development department to harmonize his teams. His Scrum Masters, elected among the team members, carried out their part-time role and continued to work on development as well. Various problems were emerging: in some teams, there was an overabundance of aspiring Scrum Masters while in others, the role had been played by the person with more seniority of service, without, however, demonstrating a great enthusiasm. Playing a role partially also reduced the focus. It provided an alibi for not devoting time to the study of coaching practices. I suggested taking advantage of the reorganization to experiment with a different method of choosing the Scrum Masters. Considering the existing constraint, which required maintaining the number of people employed (headcount), Scrum Mastery would become a full-time assignment. Each Scrum Master would be assigned to two teams. Those wishing to become Scrum Masters should apply to an internal Job Posting and pass an assessment interview held by the Coaches who led the transformation. After that, the teams would indicate their preferences among the selected people. The management would finalize the pairings, trying to satisfy as many people as possible. The idea of having full-time and professionalized Scrum Masters convinced everyone in the company, and the managers decided to experiment with this different method. The top management assured me that Scrum Master would be a role and not a mere job title. With the mantra “Job and Salary safety, Role unsafety,” the new organization was announced to the company’s entire development department. Selection Criteria I began to think about what could be the way to select candidates. Scrolling back to the book by Lyssa Atkins, “Coaching Agile Teams,” I pondered on the diversity of roles that the Agile Coach must play, and in particular on its three main functions:
- Awareness of the role and of oneself.
- The desire for the role and how they see themselves in it.
- Ability to read coaching situations.
- Practice. The practical skills as a facilitator.
- Transfer. The ability to transfer concepts, hence to teach.